It’s no secret that sales of mineral makeup have skyrocketed. Whereas it used to be available only through special television offers or unique online sites, now you can find varying brands just about anywhere. The question is: Is this makeup really better for your skin, or is it all just hype?
Mineral Makeup Contains Minerals
The big claim behind mineral makeup is that it’s more “natural” than regular makeup because it’s made from crushed, pure minerals. These include things like zinc oxide, titanium dioxide, mica, and iron oxides.
That mineral makeup contains these minerals doesn’t really set them apart, however. Take a look at your regular foundation, concealer, or blush, and you’re likely to read the same ingredients there.
So what’s the real difference? The other ingredients-or lack thereof.
Mineral Makeup Contains Fewer Potentially Toxic Ingredients
The really nice thing about mineral makeup is that it contains fewer potentially toxic ingredients than other types of makeup. I’m talking about those things I’ve suggested you avoid, like preservatives, parabens, mineral oil, chemical dyes, and fragrance. Because mineral makeup is a dry powder made of real minerals, it has a much lower likelihood of becoming contaminated with microbes and bacteria, and thus doesn’t need the preservatives. The minerals themselves have their own pretty colors, so dyes aren’t required either. Always read labels, as some brands are different than others, and unfortunately the more popular mineral makeup becomes, the more variations we’re seeing that do include these ingredients, but on the whole, mineral makeup is often the choice for people with sensitive skin who are likely to be irritated by other ingredients.
Is Mineral Makeup Good for Your Skin?
Another claim made by those selling mineral makeup is that it’s beneficial to the skin. That might be taking it a bit far. It’s not going to get rid of wrinkles or hyperpigmentation, for example. However, the titanium dioxide and zinc oxide are physical sunscreens, so there is a protective effect there, though I would still recommend you put on an additional sunscreen on most days. Zinc oxide is also a natural anti-microbial, helping to fight germs, and a natural anti-inflammatory, which may help calm sensitive skin.
What About Nanoparticles?
The biggest concern with mineral makeup is that it’s made with small particles. Some brands use “micronized” particles and others go super small with “nanoparticles.” The manufacturers are using these smaller particles so the makeup sits lightly on the skin without clogging pores. That’s why many people like mineral makeup, because it feels so light. When the particles become really small, however, there is a slight danger of inhaling them, and they can do damage in the lungs. Read my post, “Micronized Mineral Makeup” for more information and for some suggested brands that do not use nanoparticles. Choose those brands that use the larger “micronized” particles, and be sure to apply your makeup in a well ventilated area.
Should You Try Mineral Makeup?
If you have sensitive or compromised skin that is irritated by regular makeup, by all means try the mineral makeup. It may be more calming for you. Otherwise read labels and go with what feels best to you. Some people love the light feel and natural look, but others find it settles into fine lines and calls attention to dry spots. It is a powder, remember, so if you have dry skin, you’d probably be better with a safe liquid foundation.
What do you think of mineral makeup? Please let us know.
Photo courtesy dreamrdn via Flickr.com.
Great article!
I must say, “the good” mineral makeup products are so great! I find the look is so much more natural with one the added benefit of taking away the “caked” look many liquid foundations give. I personally wear the Bare Escentuals’ line and find the look and feel to be light and fresh, foundation tones match complexions appropriately.
Myth or reality? Though I know the importance of washing your face every night, I heard one great feature of minerals is that if you have a tough day and fall asleep w/makeup on, it’s not bad for your skin? Is this true?
Nicole
Hi, Nicole. Thanks for sharing your experience, and for your question. I would say always, always wash the makeup off your face before bed. Leaving makeup on your skin not only traps bacteria and oils in your pores, increasing the risk of acne and blackheads, but it also leaves all the pollutants, free radicals, and the like on your face that you accumulated throughout the day. In addition, you miss out on the opportunity to help your skin recover and repair with your night creams and serums.
That said, I think the point is that if you miss a night, having mineral makeup on your face may cause less damage than other types of makeup. I think this depends on the ingredients in the makeup, as even mineral makeups are different from one another, but they may be better than other foundations that are full of toxic ingredients. But bottom line—it takes less than 3 minutes, so please wash and apply your night creams. Your skin will thank you!
I liked your post on mineral make up. Would you recommend specific brands of mineral make up available in South Africa?
Thank you.
Hi, Carlen. Thanks for writing in from so far away! As I’m in the U.S., I’m afraid I can’t recommend any brands near you, but maybe some of our readers will help out. Meanwhile, you can do your own research—just check the ingredient lists on the products you’re considering, and look at their websites as well to see if they’re committed to using safe and nourishing ingredients. Let us know if you find something wonderful!
I’ve had eye makeup allergies since forever. I tried an “all natural” mineral makeup that came highly recommended. I’m allergic to it, too. My eyes swelled up, and it took MONTHS to get them to settle down. I used to be able to at least tolerate mascara, but no more.
I love my fruit-pigmented cosmetics from 100% Pure. You can see them at boutiquebrands.us and shipping is free is your 100% Pure order of $50 or more. Just confirm Holly Petrie is shown as your consultant at checkout. BTW, no nanoparticles!
Great post Britta. I second your concern on nanoparticles, especially those in a powder form. For more on nano’s check out, http://mvorganicsblog.com/safety-health-nanotech-issues/ . I also find that powder mineral make-up accentuates the wrinkles so I much prefer liquid coverage with SPF. Here’s my new fav, http://mvorganics.com/_product_83436/Everyday_Sheer_Coverage%2c_Light_Tint
I love mineral makeup, whether it’s liquid or powder. I tend to go with powder because of the heat and humidity where I live, liquid would just melt off anyway. Plus I have pretty good skin and need less coverage. I’ve experienced what you mention though when it comes to more commercialized mineral makeup. It’s horrible how they sneak in bad ingredients because many women think just because it’s “Mineral” makeup, it’s healthier. You made some great points!